We love this pretty bow skirt by Tibi...

But who do you think it looks best on? Emma Bunton or Cheryl Cole?

Emma Bunton wore the Tibi skirt first to Cheryl's birthday party... we wonder if Miss Cole liked it so much she asked Emma where she got it from and bought it herself!

We tracked the skirt down on Net-a-Porter for £195 - eek!

So, now you have to decide who you think looked better... Emma wore hers at night with a black skirt, black platform courts and a black oversized bag...

Cheryl wore hers to the X Factor auditions a couple of weeks later, she wore hers with a white shirt, a pretty pink beaded necklave and shiny purple court shoes...

So, now you know what to do - let us know you think wore it best!

Comments please!

If you like comparing outfits, see lots more who wore it best articles on sugarscape.com right here!