Two ladies looking pretty in pink...


But who wore it best?

It's American Idol winner vs Baywatch actress in this pink Jenny Packham dress fashion frock-off!

Carrie Underwood wore her dress with bauble earrings, a silver clutch and platform peep toe heels and did you spot that extra accessory? Hello Kitty plasters covering a booboo on her knee!

Carmen Electra wore her dress with a glowing tan, her hair tied back and super sparkly sandals...

So there you have it! Two beautiful ladies in one beautiful dress! Can you decide who wore it best?

Comments please!

Do you like deciding who wore it best? See lots more on sugarscape.com right here!