Paris Hilton and Jordin Sparks are both fans of the bad gal biker look, but who wears studs with more style?

Paris wore this studded, exposed zip dress by Bebe, back in the days of stepping out with Doug, for a party at exclusive bar H.Wood in L.A

She went for an edgy look and teamed it up with a black leather jacket, Louboutin ankle boots and one of her famous silver hairbands.

Jordin wore the same dress for her recent American Idol performance and went for a more polished look with skyscraper heels, perfectly preened hair and a giant cocktail ring.

But who pulls of the Bebe dress with the most attitude? Does Paris make a convincing bad gal, or does the dress look better on Jordin's curves?